diff --git a/compiler/stgSyn/CoreToStg.hs b/compiler/stgSyn/CoreToStg.hs
index e8f159b56925f0cc0183e80f0a5962cc47db3a98..f53a5d4e9f3ac415690c6bfaee55a1c4a28ded59 100644
--- a/compiler/stgSyn/CoreToStg.hs
+++ b/compiler/stgSyn/CoreToStg.hs
@@ -268,7 +268,7 @@ coreTopBindToStg dflags this_mod env ccs (NonRec id rhs)
 
         bind = StgTopLifted $ StgNonRec id stg_rhs
     in
-    ASSERT2(consistentCafInfo id bind, ppr id )
+    assertConsistentCaInfo dflags id bind (ppr bind)
       -- NB: previously the assertion printed 'rhs' and 'bind'
       --     as well as 'id', but that led to a black hole
       --     where printing the assertion error tripped the
@@ -296,9 +296,18 @@ coreTopBindToStg dflags this_mod env ccs (Rec pairs)
 
         bind = StgTopLifted $ StgRec (zip binders stg_rhss)
     in
-    ASSERT2(consistentCafInfo (head binders) bind, ppr binders)
+    assertConsistentCaInfo dflags (head binders) bind (ppr binders)
     (env', ccs', bind)
 
+-- | CAF consistency issues will generally result in segfaults and are quite
+-- difficult to debug (see #16846). We enable checking of the
+-- 'consistentCafInfo' invariant with @-dstg-lint@ to increase the chance that
+-- we catch these issues.
+assertConsistentCaInfo :: DynFlags -> Id -> StgTopBinding -> SDoc -> a -> a
+assertConsistentCaInfo dflags id bind err_doc result
+  | gopt Opt_DoStgLinting dflags || debugIsOn
+  , not $ consistentCafInfo id bind = pprPanic "assertConsistentCaInfo" err_doc
+  | otherwise = result
 
 -- Assertion helper: this checks that the CafInfo on the Id matches
 -- what CoreToStg has figured out about the binding's SRT.  The